Dear Friends:
Today was a tragic day. I didn't know
anyone involved in the shooting in Connecticut nor have I
(thankfully) ever had to experience what they did, but my heart goes
out to them none the less on this senseless and sadly preventable
day.
I have been reading your facebook
posts all day and amidst the anger of this incident is outrage, that
yet again we have another string of victims who could have been saved
through fairly reasonable means and pleas to allow this to be the
incident that wakes us up. That finally show our political opposites
that a small degree of regulation, sensibly written and applied, is
not going to send us spiraling into Hell. I find myself asking the
same questions. Unfortunately I also find myself coming to
inevitable answers.
No.
No this will not be the thing that
shines fresh light on the subject.
No this will not be the water shed
moment that the right abandons it's hard headed obstinacy.
No this will not be the tragedy that
finally gets us all to the table looking for a real solution to gun
violence.
We will be accused of politicizing the
tragedy, as if such events aren't always politicized as with the
drive to war following 9/11 or the NRA convention in the Denver
suburbs after Columbine.
The right will toss tired and debunked
straw man arguments that have nothing to do with the current tragedy
(I am a gun owner and avid participant in shooting sports and have
many times been told
I want to ban guns)
I want to ban guns)
The right will make outrageous claims
that if the kids had been carrying guns this could have been avoided.
In fact already I have read someone advocating that if the teachers
had been allowed to carry guns this wouldn't have happened. Which
assumes that the teachers WOULD have carried guns and that a shoot
out would not have occurred and even after that still ends up with
some people dead.
This is because the right are not
entering this debate as honest actors. They may think they are, but
what they really are coming in as is fundamentalists. They have no
interest in common sense. They have no interest in reexamining their
own beliefs, even just to double check their validity. They have a
near religious belief that if everyone can have guns then everyone
will and crime will stop. This belief is not held up by numbers.
The highest rates of gun crimes are in states that have loose gun
laws. They have a blind adherence to the second half of the second
amendment. The first half refers to a militia and makes it clear
that the right to bear arms is meant for national defense against the
government and not personal protection. They will not even agree the
while the mentally ill should be allowed to have guns it would be
better for us all if the criminally insane Didn't have them. We are
not going to win on gun control at this time.
There is hope. The right has already
started sandbagging against any and all attempts at even the meekest
legislation. But there is another avenue to help prevent tragedies
such as this. In all of the mass shootings of the past several years
the perpetrator has been mentally ill. When considered it's kind of
a crazy thing to do after all. So while they build bunkers on the
supply side. They will leave their demand side flank uncovered.
Naomi Klein wrote about the Shock Doctrine which uses tragedy to pull
us into fear and war. It can be used for good.
The discussion of gun control is a discussion of means. It is ultimately tangential to the problem. What we need, is s discussion of cause. Those who are so busy prepping against the imagined assault on their guns have no answer for how to avoid the cause of these tragedies. They claim more guns may reduce body counts but their demagoguing cannot not even conceive of prevention. So it falls to us.
Now is the time to call for
comprehensive mental care for the mentally ill.
Now is the time get your
representatives to demand that we treat those who are mentally ill as
people and not just cast them to the wolves.
Now is the time to try and treat the
problem at it's source. They make a good point, that banning guns
will not solve the problem. So let's focus on solving the problem
before it starts.
It might seem tasteless to bring this
up now. But if we don't act fast we will be leaving the next school,
theater, shopping mall waiting for the next tragedy.